top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
Search

Just Because You Can Doesn't Mean You Should

Nov 7
9 min read


Why I'm questioning what we've been taught to celebrate in fitness, sports, and the culture of pushing through everything.


I've been thinking about something lately, especially with everything going on in my own life and some of the things I've been seeing in the fitness world. Why are we so obsessed with pushing through everything, and when did that become the ultimate measure of strength?


And I get it. I really do. I've been an athlete for most of my life. I grew up competing in alpine skiing, played volleyball, and now I compete in Olympic weightlifting. I know what it's like to challenge yourself, push your limits, and see what you're capable of. There's something pretty damn amazing about accomplishing something you weren't sure you could do, and I wouldn't trade those experiences for anything.


But sometimes I find myself watching what's happening around me and thinking, "Are you fucking kidding me?" Not because I'm trying to judge anyone, but because I genuinely wonder what we've been conditioned to believe about strength, determination, and what it means to be a dedicated athlete.


I don't know someone else's circumstances, what conversations they've had with medical professionals, or what they're experiencing in their own body, and frankly, that's none of my business. What interests me is the bigger picture and why we seem to admire people most when they're willing to push through absolutely anything.


When Did Suffering Become Something to Celebrate?

Think about how often we see stories celebrating someone who finished a competition despite being injured, exhausted, or physically struggling. The comments are usually filled with people praising their determination, grit, and refusal to quit. And sometimes those accomplishments really are incredible. I'm not taking that away from anyone, but I do wonder how often we stop to consider whether continuing was actually the best decision.


And let's be real, where did we learn that pushing ourselves to the point of potentially harming ourselves is something to celebrate? Was it the coaches telling us to suck it up, the fitness industry selling us the idea that pain equals progress, or social media turning every extreme physical accomplishment into another inspirational video?


Somewhere along the way, we started confusing suffering with success, and I don't know about you, but I'm getting pretty tired of that narrative.


Growing up as a competitive athlete, I learned how much dedication, discipline, and perseverance matter. Those experiences shaped who I am, and I still value them. But as I've gotten older, especially now that I'm competing as a master's weightlifter, I've started questioning some of the messages we carry with us from sports. Not because I suddenly think challenging ourselves is a bad thing, but because being competitive and making thoughtful decisions shouldn't be mutually exclusive.


When Do We Say Enough Is Enough?

Unless you've been avoiding social media altogether, there's a good chance you've seen the video of the HYROX athlete who shit herself during a competition and kept going. It was all over social media, and while plenty of people had something to say about it, what really caught my attention wasn't that her body did something unexpected. It was that she continued competing and nobody stopped her.


And this isn't the first time we've seen something like this. I've seen stories and videos of marathon runners shitting themselves during races, too. Somewhere along the way, these moments have become part of the conversation about endurance, toughness, and just how far athletes are willing to push themselves.

But seriously, when do we say enough is enough? When does finishing a race stop being about determination and start becoming a question of public health and safety?


Think about it this way. If someone shits in a public swimming pool, everyone has to get out while the pool is treated and made safe again. Nobody stands around debating whether the person should be allowed to finish their laps because they've trained so hard. We recognize that other people are sharing that space and that their health matters, too.


So why do we seem to have different expectations when it comes to running events or competitions like HYROX?


We're still talking about people sharing spaces, touching equipment, and potentially coming into contact with bodily waste. Obviously, cleaning a swimming pool isn't the same as cleaning a racecourse or exercise equipment, but the responsibility to protect other participants doesn't disappear because someone is chasing a personal record.


And here's where I think we need to have a much bigger conversation about HYROX itself. Where were the officials? Why wasn't someone stepping in to address the contamination and protect the other competitors? Why are we putting so much emphasis on whether the athlete should have stopped without also questioning why the organizers allowed her to continue?


HYROX later acknowledged that officials should have intervened. Its co-founder, Moritz Fürste, publicly apologized for the organization's failure to respond immediately, and HYROX subsequently changed its rules to allow race directors to remove athletes when bodily fluids create a contamination or welfare risk.

I'm glad those changes were made, but I still have questions. Why weren't those expectations clearer before this happened? And what does it say about our sporting culture when an organization has rules about things like spitting or littering on the course, but hadn't clearly addressed a situation involving fecal contamination?


The athlete, Joanna Wietrzyk, later apologized for her decision to continue racing and voluntarily withdrew her result and forfeited her points. I think that distinction matters. She shouldn't be shamed for having a bodily accident. Bodies are unpredictable, especially during intense physical activity. But recognizing that her decision affected other people is a different conversation, and I appreciate that she took responsibility.


And I also think HYROX deserves credit for acknowledging its failure. But acknowledging a mistake doesn't mean we stop asking questions about how it happened or what needs to change.


Because here's what really bothers me. We have an entire fitness culture that celebrates pushing through discomfort, ignoring limits, and finishing no matter what. Event organizers are part of that culture, too. They help shape what gets rewarded, what gets celebrated, and what athletes believe is expected of them.

We can't keep telling athletes to push through everything and then act surprised when they do. And we can't expect someone in the middle of an intense competition, with adrenaline running high and their attention focused on finishing, to carry the entire responsibility for making the right decision while the people running the event stand by.


The athlete had a responsibility to the people around her, and the organization had a responsibility to intervene. Both things can be true.


Are We Challenging Ourselves or Trying to Prove Something?

I've been coaching movement for over 12 years, and one thing I've learned is that there's a difference between challenging yourself and feeling like you have something to prove. I think sometimes we get those two things confused, and I'm including myself in that conversation because I've certainly had moments when my competitive brain wanted one thing while the rest of me was questioning whether it was a good idea.


And here's something else I've learned through my work as a trauma-informed coach. We don't always know what's driving someone's need to keep going. For some people, pushing through discomfort has been praised their entire lives. For others, saying no, asking for help, or admitting something doesn't feel right may not have always been met with understanding or support. And sometimes it's simply that competitive part of us that really wants to finish what we started.


That's why I think it's important to approach these conversations with curiosity instead of immediately making assumptions about someone's choices. We don't know their history, what they've experienced, or what they've been taught about strength and success. And we certainly can't determine any of that by watching a video or observing someone at the gym.


But being curious about someone's experience doesn't mean we ignore accountability. We can recognize that someone's decisions may be influenced by their experiences while still acknowledging when those decisions affect other people. I think there's room for both compassion and responsibility, and frankly, I wish we saw more of that in fitness.


I'm not going to pretend I know what was going through Wietrzyk's mind during that race, and I'm certainly not going to speculate about her personal history. What I am interested in is how the environments we create influence the decisions people make, especially when there's pressure to perform.


As coaches, I think we have a responsibility to create environments where athletes feel comfortable speaking up, asking questions, and making decisions about their bodies without worrying that they'll be judged or seen as less dedicated. That doesn't mean we stop challenging people or encouraging them to grow. It means we recognize that how someone experiences a challenge matters just as much as the challenge itself.


One thing I've learned from coaching is that two people can be doing the exact same movement and have completely different experiences. I can't look at someone and automatically know what they're feeling, what they're working through, or why they're making certain decisions. That's why I ask questions, why I listen, and why I'm not interested in being the coach who tells someone to push harder simply because I think they should be able to.


And I think that's especially important when we're working with people who may have spent years being told to ignore their discomfort, push through pain, or prove their worth through physical performance.


Who Benefits From This Version of Strength?

We've created this narrative that the toughest person in the room is the one who keeps going no matter what, but is that really what strength looks like? And who benefits from that narrative? The athlete, the coach, the fitness industry, or the social media platforms that turn these moments into viral content?


Because social media adds another layer to all of this. Someone's most vulnerable moment can become content for millions of strangers, and suddenly everyone has an opinion. We watch, comment, share, and make assumptions about people we know absolutely nothing about. Sometimes we praise them for being tough, and other times we tear them apart for making a mistake.


And I think that's worth examining, too. Wietrzyk has since spoken publicly about how difficult the backlash was for her and her family, including threats directed at them. We can have a serious conversation about sanitation, safety, and accountability without turning someone's humiliating experience into an opportunity for public cruelty.


That's part of what bothers me about the way fitness and sports are presented online. We take complicated human experiences, reduce them to a short video, and decide whether someone deserves to be celebrated or condemned. There's very little room for context, curiosity, or recognizing that people can make mistakes and still deserve to be treated with dignity.


And meanwhile, the bigger conversations about the organizations, expectations, and systems surrounding those moments can get lost.


I love being an athlete. I love competing, and I love seeing people discover what their bodies are capable of, especially when they've spent years being told what they can't do. I don't want us to lose that excitement or sense of accomplishment.

But loving competition doesn't mean I have to agree with everything we've been taught about what makes someone a strong athlete. And it certainly doesn't mean I have to celebrate every decision someone makes in the name of determination.


Maybe It's Time We Asked a Different Question

I don't have all the answers, and I'm not pretending I've always made the best decisions as an athlete either. But after spending most of my life in sports and more than 12 years coaching movement, I think it's worth questioning some of the things we've accepted as normal.




What would happen if we started celebrating athletes for making thoughtful decisions instead of only praising them for pushing through everything? What if coaches were recognized for creating environments where athletes felt comfortable speaking up, and event organizers were expected to prioritize the well-being of everyone participating, even when that meant interrupting a competition?


And what if we stopped treating someone's most embarrassing or vulnerable moment as entertainment and started asking better questions about the culture surrounding it?


Because if we're going to keep talking about building stronger athletes, maybe we should spend a little more time talking about the environments we're creating for them and what we're teaching them to value.


The next time we see someone pushing through something extreme, maybe instead of immediately celebrating their toughness, we should ask whether continuing was really the right decision, who else might have been affected, and whether someone should have stepped in.


After all, just because you can doesn't mean you should.


About the Author

Wendy Welsher is the founder of My JAMM (My Joyous Adaptive Momentous Movement), a USA Weightlifting Level 2 coach, Precision Nutrition coach, and lifelong athlete with over 12 years of experience coaching movement. Her work centers on trauma-informed, weight-inclusive fitness, body autonomy, and creating welcoming spaces where people of all abilities can discover strength and joy in movement.

Learn more at www.myjamm.rocks.


 
 
 

Comments


Get Your Free Learn to Lift Guide

©2026 by MyJamm LLC.

Created with Wix.com

Sacramento, California
wendy@myjamm.rocks

bottom of page