top of page
Search
Writer's pictureWendy JIMJAMM Welsher

Why Cutting Calories Isn't the Answer


Menopause is a big transition in a person's life, bringing all sorts of changes, including how the body handles weight. Many folks find themselves struggling with weight gain and often try cutting calories as a solution. But guess what? This approach can backfire. Research shows that eating enough and adding weight training are key to managing weight and balancing hormones during menopause. In this blog, we'll dive into why cutting calories isn't the best idea and how proper nutrition and strength training can make for a healthier, more balanced menopausal journey.



The Misconception of Cutting Calories

The Calorie Myth

The usual advice says weight loss is all about calories in vs. calories out. While that might work for some, things get trickier during menopause due to hormonal changes. Menopause brings its own set of challenges that can make losing weight harder for women. Dr. Kathryn A. Bollinger, a menopause expert, explains that hormonal shifts, especially the drop in estrogen, can change how your body stores fat and processes energy. This can lead to more belly fat and a slower metabolism, making it tougher to lose weight. Plus, menopause can mess with your sleep and energy levels, adding another layer of difficulty. So, understanding and tackling these hormonal changes is key to effective weight loss during this phase.


Research Insights

A study in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism found that severe calorie restriction can seriously slow down your metabolism, meaning your body burns fewer calories even when you're resting. This "starvation mode" can make losing weight harder and keeping it off even trickier. Plus, once you start eating normally again, your body might store more calories as fat to recover from the restriction. This just goes to show how important it is to take a balanced approach to dieting and weight management.


Why Do We Think Restricting is the Way?

The Less is More Mentality

We've all heard it over and over: the idea that eating less equals losing weight. This "less is more" mindset is deeply rooted in our society, fueled by the belief that cutting calories will lead to a trimmer body. The prevailing diet culture and media often glorify this concept, promoting drastic calorie cuts and quick weight loss as the ultimate keys to fitness success.


Psychological Appeal

Calorie restriction can have a strong psychological allure. The concept that consuming fewer calories equates to weight loss can be highly appealing. It's easy to see why individuals may gravitate towards the notion that a simple reduction in caloric intake can yield rapid outcomes, all without the need for a complete overhaul of one's lifestyle, dietary habits, or exercise routine. This perception of simplicity and quick results without extensive changes is a common draw for those considering calorie restriction as a weight management strategy.


Temporary Results

Certainly, it's common knowledge that cutting calories can initially result in rapid weight loss. However, it's crucial to understand the underlying mechanisms. When caloric intake is reduced, the body adjusts by slowing down metabolism. This adaptation can often result in frustrating weight plateaus and a higher risk of regaining lost weight. For individuals aiming for sustainable weight management, this cycle can pose a significant challenge.


The Importance of Eating Enough

Choosing Food for Fuel

When estrogen levels drop, it's super important to get the right nutrition to keep your body running smoothly and your hormones in check. Your body's needs are changing, so proper nutrition is even more crucial now. Not eating enough can lead to nutrient deficiencies, making menopausal symptoms like fatigue, mood swings, and bone loss even worse.


During menopause, your metabolism can slow down, making it easier to gain weight and harder to lose it. That's why a balanced diet rich in calcium, vitamin D, and other essential nutrients is key. Think leafy greens, nuts, seeds, and dairy for bone density, and lean proteins and whole grains for muscle mass and energy. Don't forget to stay hydrated and get regular physical activity to help manage symptoms and boost your overall well-being.


By paying close attention to what you eat, you can navigate this phase of life with greater ease and comfort.


Nutritional Needs During Menopause

Ensuring foods in vitamins and minerals helps support overall health, maintain energy levels, and mitigate the impact of these symptoms. Food that includes a variety of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins can provide the necessary nutrients your body needs. Additionally, staying hydrated by drinking plenty of water is crucial for optimal bodily functions. Remember, consulting with a healthcare provider or a nutritionist can provide personalized guidance tailored to your specific needs during this transitional phase. They can help create a meal plan that addresses deficiencies and supports your well-being, ensuring you get the most out of your  lifestyle adjustments.


Balanced Diet and Hormone Health

Eating a diet full of whole foods—like fruits, veggies, lean proteins, healthy fats, and whole grains—gives your body the essential nutrients it needs to support hormone production and overall health. These nutrients include vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and fiber, all of which play critical roles in maintaining bodily functions. Dr. Susan R. Davis has highlighted in her research that a balanced diet helps keep blood sugar levels steady, which is key for hormonal balance. Additionally, maintaining steady blood sugar can prevent energy crashes and mood swings, further contributing to a more stable and healthy lifestyle.


How Food Makes You Feel

Noticing how different foods make you feel can really help with better dietary choices. Foods that keep your blood sugar steady, like complex carbs and proteins, can help maintain your energy levels and reduce mood swings. Think whole grains, beans, and lean meats for sustained energy throughout the day. On the flip side, processed foods and sugars, like sugary snacks and fast food, can lead to energy crashes and make symptoms like hot flashes worse. Over time, making mindful choices about what you eat can have a big impact on your overall well-being and mood stability.


The Role of Weight Training

Muscle Mass and Metabolism

To prevent menopausal weight gain effectively, consider adding weight training to your workout routine. As women age and go through menopause, they often face a decline in muscle mass. Engaging in strength training not only helps maintain current muscle mass but also fosters new muscle growth, vital for a healthy metabolism. This boost in muscle mass can elevate your metabolic rate, enabling your body to burn more calories even at rest. Weight training is key to supporting overall health and weight management during menopause.


Hormonal Benefits

Weight training has been shown to have a beneficial impact on hormone levels. For instance, a study published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research highlighted that engaging in consistent resistance training sessions can lead to enhancements in insulin sensitivity. This, in turn, may help in lowering levels of cortisol, a stress hormone closely linked to weight gain.


Combining Nutrition and Exercise for Optimal Health



Practical Tips

  1. Eat Adequate Protein: Ensure each meal contains a source of lean protein to support muscle maintenance and repair.

  2. Incorporate Healthy Fats: Include sources of omega-3 fatty acids, like fish and flaxseed, which have anti-inflammatory properties and support heart health.

  3. Strength Training Routine: Aim for at least two to three sessions of weight training per week, focusing on major muscle groups.

  4. Stay Hydrated: Proper hydration is essential for metabolic processes and overall health.

  5. Choose Foods for Fuel: Focus on how foods make you feel. Prioritize whole, nutrient-dense foods that provide lasting energy and support hormone balance.

  6. Monitor Portion Sizes: Pay attention to portion sizes, but don't overly restrict. Ensure you're getting enough food to fuel your body effectively.


My Personal Journey

As someone who has been active for the last 16 years, I initially fell into the trap of cutting calories to manage my weight during menopause. Despite my regular physical activity, I found myself constantly fatigued and irritable, and my weight seemed to stay stubbornly the same. This approach led me down a dangerous path of eating disorders and disordered exercising. My obsession with cutting calories and over-exercising took a toll on my mental and physical health.


Coming to terms with my eating disorder was a pivotal moment in my journey. With professional help, I began to understand the importance of healing my relationship with food and movement. Instead of depriving my body of necessary nutrients, I started focusing on fueling it properly. I incorporated more whole foods into my diet—lean proteins, healthy fats, and plenty of fruits and vegetables.


Even with my established fitness routine, shifting my mindset towards a more balanced approach to exercise, including weight training, became a game-changer. Not only did I begin to feel stronger, but I also noticed improvements in my mood and energy levels. Weight training helped me build muscle, which in turn boosted my metabolism. This holistic approach to diet and exercise made a significant difference in managing my menopausal symptoms and achieving a healthier weight.


Real-Life Success Stories

Many women have found success in managing their menopausal symptoms by focusing less on calorie counting and more on eating nutrient-rich foods and doing regular strength training. Instead of just cutting calories, this approach highlights the importance of eating foods packed with vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients.


Take Jane, for example. She's a 52-year-old teacher from New York who shared that after adding weight training and nutrient dense foods to her routine, she not only unintentionally lost weight but also felt more energetic and had fewer hot flashes. Jane's new additions includes more leafy greens, lean proteins, and whole grains, which helped her feel better overall. Plus, her regular strength training sessions helped her build muscle and boost her metabolism, making it easier to keep the weight off.


This holistic approach has empowered many women like Jane to take control of their health and enjoy a more vibrant, symptom-free life during menopause.


Conclusion

The journey through menopause doesn’t have to feel like you’re battling your own body. By understanding the unique hormonal changes that happen during this phase and tweaking your approach to nutrition and exercise, you can live a healthier, more balanced life. Menopause brings shifts in estrogen and progesterone levels, affecting everything from your metabolism to mood.


Instead of just cutting calories to manage weight, focus on eating the right foods that nourish you. Think leafy greens, lean proteins, whole grains, and healthy fats—they’re all great for your overall health. Plus, regular weight training isn’t just about maintaining muscle; it’s also great for your bone density and metabolism.


Remember, the goal isn’t just to lose weight but to improve overall health and well-being. Embracing this holistic approach can help ease common menopause symptoms like fatigue and weight gain, while also giving you a sense of empowerment and control over your health during this significant life transition.


References

  1. Bollinger, K. A., et al. "Menopause and Metabolic Health." Journal of Women's Health (2020).

  2. Smith, R. N., et al. "Caloric Restriction and Metabolic Rate." Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (2018).

  3. Davis, S. R., et al. "Dietary Interventions for Hormonal Balance in Menopause." Nutrition Journal (2019).

  4. Phillips, S. M., et al. "Muscle Health and Resistance Training." Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research (2017).

  5. Fahey, T. D., et al. "Hormonal Responses to Resistance Training." Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research (2019).

Interested in learning more from a menopause dietitian? Explore the expertise of Dr. Jenn Salib Huber, RD ND.

103 views1 comment

1 Comment


Hallo, mein Name ist Jamanyama. Meine Erfahrung bei Dolly Casino war insgesamt positiv https://dolly.casinologinde.com/. Das Design der Seite ist modern und das Einloggen war kinderleicht. Es gibt viele interessante Slots, und die Vielfalt der Spiele hat mich beeindruckt. Die Auszahlungen wurden zügig bearbeitet, und der Kundensupport war immer zur Stelle, wenn ich Hilfe brauchte. Die Bonusangebote sind ebenfalls attraktiv und erhöhen den Spielspaß. Ich werde definitiv wieder bei Dolly Casino spielen.

Like
bottom of page